Select Page

Wisconsin, the 30th state admitted to the union, is affectionately known as America’s Dairyland. It’s home to the only community-owned professional sports franchise in the US, the Green Bay Packers. With a variety of beautiful parks and lakes dotting the state, it has a lot to offer nature lovers as well.

To appreciate the outdoors in Wisconsin, a vehicle is needed. If you have a vehicle, you need auto insurance. In this state, the following coverage minimums are required by law for vehicle owners:

$25,000:$50,000:$10,000:

  • $25,000: This amount covers the bodily injury or death of one person in an accident.
  • $50,000: This is the amount allotted for the injury or death of more than one person during an accident.
  • $10,000: This amount covers damage inflicted on another person’s property during an accident.

Auto insurance is a necessity, but it can also be expensive. The average resident here pays $733 yearly to have their vehicle insured, but rates can vary dramatically depending on the company and location. Generally, people don’t want to pay more than they have to for anything. For this reason, we’ve compiled a list of the cheapest auto insurance companies in Wisconsin for each of the state’s five biggest cities.

Cheapest Auto Insurance Companies by City

Milwaukee, WI

Milwaukee is the largest city in Wisconsin. The city is renowned for its brewing industry – they even have a baseball team named after it: The Milwaukee Brewers.

Auto insurance prices here are high at an average of $1,411 annually – nearly twice the state average. With prices so high, it’s important to shop around for the best deal. USAA offers policies averaging $570, although it’s limited to military members. For others, GEICO also offers great value at around $636. Here’s the full list of cheap companies in Milwaukee:

Madison, WI

  • USAA
  • GEICO
  • Auto-Owners
  • Farmers
  • Auto Club Group

Madison is Wisconsin’s capital, and second biggest city. It’s also a great place to live. In fact, it has ranked among the best places to live in the US in numerous publications, including the #1 ranking in Money Magazine in 1996.

Auto insurance here is reasonably priced at an average annual rate of $701, just below the state average. There are still a lot of savings to be had however, with companies like Partners Mutual offering rates as low as $336:

Green Bay, WI

  • Partners Mutual
  • GEICO
  • USAA
  • Western Mutual
  • Auto Club Group

Green Bay, Wisconsin’s third largest city, is home to a number of colleges, museums, and parks. But this city is predominantly known for one thing: The Green Bay Packers. They are the smallest professional sports market in the country by far, something the community takes great pride in.

Auto insurance here is quite reasonable, with average rates at around $652 per year. For the best deals, look into these companies:

Kenosha, WI

  • GEICO
  • USAA
  • Partners Mutual
  • Auto Club Group
  • Western National

Ranking as the state’s fourth largest city, Kenosha is a great place for outdoor activities during the summer. Golf is particularly popular here, with the Petrifying Springs Golf Course being named ranked as the state’s #1 course by the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel.

Auto insurance rates run above the state average here, with residents paying $841 yearly. Check out these companies for better rates:

Racine, WI

  • GEICO
  • USAA
  • Auto Club Group
  • Western National
  • State Farm

Racine, the fifth biggest city in the state, is also one of the most affordable, with median home prices of just over $100,000. Unfortunately, the city’s auto insurance rates don’t fall in line, running above the state average at $827 per year. You can get cheaper insurance at the following companies:

  • GEICO
  • USAA
  • Western National
  • Auto Club Group
  • State Farm