Tyron Jones

Car Insurance Expert
Updated: 1/2019

Tyron Jones is a car insurance expert who has operated within the auto insurance business for more than 10 years. 

Choosing the right insurance company is a complicated process – you want to make sure you have a strong policy at an affordable price. While price often dominates the conversation about insurance companies, it’s essential that you understand many more factors are at play. You need to consider the other benefits provided by the insurer, as well as the reliability of the insurance company that you’re working with. If you want to find a cheap car insurance company, you need to do the research.

In this article, we’ll provide you with some information on choosing the top cheap car insurance companies on the market. Make sure to read all the available information before you start your auto insurance decision-making process.

Cheap Car Insurance Companies

Cheap Auto Insurance Companies

Navigate

Assess Your Priorities

The first step to finding cheap auto insurance is to assess your priorities as a consumer. You don’t want to spend money on policies that won’t directly impact you as a driver. By determining what you want from an auto insurance policy, you’ll be able to choose a policy that is affordable and suited to your needs. Also, you might be able to find a policy that has specific benefits that help improve your coverage.

For example, if you’re someone who is categorized as a ‘high-risk’ driver, you might have to find an insurance policy that is open to insuring people with poor driving records. Certain insurance companies might not offer affordable plans to high-risk individuals. If you’re someone who is a new driver, you may want to find an insurance company that offers cheaper rates for students or responsible driving discounts – insurance policies for new drivers can often be very expensive if you choose the wrong insurance company.

State and Neighborhood Matters

It’s impossible to know the cheapest insurance company without providing personal location information – especially if you’re aiming to purchase a comprehensive insurance plan. Auto insurance companies will provide different quotes depending on the state that you live in. This is because auto insurance companies assess risk depending on driving condition, traffic data, state laws, and other factors that may determine the potential risk of damage or theft.

In terms of neighborhoods, auto insurance companies will also look at data to understand how safe your neighborhood is. If you purchase a comprehensive insurance plan in a dangerous neighborhood, it may cost a lot of money – this is because of the amount of risk of theft in certain neighborhoods. Make sure to get a direct quote from an auto insurance company before deciding which auto insurance plan is right for you and your location.

Which States Are Most Expensive for Auto Insurance?

The most expensive states in the country are Michigan and Louisiana. Annual insurance premiums in these states tend to be over $2,000 a year. In Michigan, rates appear to be extremely high because of local government laws and regulations making the insurance industry more expensive for insurers. Also, there appears to be a large amount of insurance fraud in Michigan, which raises the prices for everyone.

In Louisiana, insurance rates appear to be high because of the number of uninsured drivers on the roads. This makes accidents much more expensive for people that are insured. Also, there is a lot of accident litigation in Louisiana, as suing is commonplace in road accidents. This also raises the cost of doing business in the state of Louisiana.

States with Cheapest Auto Insurance Policies

The two states with the cheapest auto insurance policies are Maine and Idaho. These two states benefit from insurance premiums that are typically under $1,000 a year. The reason behind this is most likely linked to the rural nature of the two states. Rural states tend to have fewer claims than more densely populated, urban states.

Cheap Auto Insurance Companies

Best Auto Insurance for Under-18s (New Drivers)

Progressive

If you’re looking to obtain a new insurance policy for someone who is under the age of 18, Progressive is one of your best options. They have under-18 discounts that almost appear too good to be true. You can receive extra discounts from progressive if you are under-18 and have good grades at school – a ‘B’ average is typically required for this discount.

On top of this, Progressive allows parents to include their children on their insurance – which can then provide coverage for all cars. This is also a great option if you have a child under the age of 18 that will be using your car. If your family has multiple cars because of under-18 drivers, Progressive also offers multi-car discounts that ensure you don’t have to pay full price to insure each vehicle your family owns.

Best Auto Insurance for Cheap Discounts

Travelers

Travelers is a great option if you’re looking for an insurance company that provides an array of different discounts for drivers. Travelers is committed to providing industry-leading discounts that can help make your policy one of the cheapest auto insurance policies on the market. They have safe-driver discounts, homeowner discounts, continuous insurance discounts, new car discounts, early quote discounts, good student discounts, and more.

They even provide discounts for people who pay their bill electronically. They know how to provide value in their policies!

Best Auto Insurance for Rideshare Drivers (Uber and Lyft Drivers)

Allstate

Ridesharing poses several challenges for drivers that want insurance coverage – some insurance companies don’t allow ridesharing at all. Fortunately, Allstate has a ridesharing-specific program that helps ridesharing drivers insure their cars at all times. They offer their ridesharing coverage in 40 states of the US – check their website for the most recent list of eligible ridesharing states.

Cheap Auto Insurance Companies

Popular Auto Insurance Companies

If you’re interested in other cheap auto insurance companies, you’ve come to the right place. We’ve taken a look at some of the other cheap auto insurance companies on the market to help you determine if they’re the right insurance company for you. We compiled a comprehensive list of cheap auto insurance companies. Below are brief reviews of most of the major auto insurance providers in the nation – check it out!

Allstate

Allstate is one of the largest and most recognized insurance agencies on the US consumer market. The firm is well-known for its aggressive advertising campaigns and range of additional benefits. Overall, Allstate is a strong performer – they offer 24/7 claims assistance, online account management, quick claim processing, and plenty of additional resources and customer services. The only downside is that they’re slightly more expensive than some of the more competitive companies on the market.

Ameriprise Financial

Ameriprise Financial is another large insurance company that has plenty of benefits for consumers. The company is well known for having over ten discounts and low premiums for responsible drivers. In addition, they have one of the best-rated customer service teams in the industry. If you’re looking for a mix of discounts and customer care, this is a solid option.

Amica

Amica is an auto insurance company well-known for having watertight vehicle coverage – they focus on proving some of the best damage coverage on the market. Also, they allow you to add-on plenty of other coverage options to protect you or your vehicle from all sorts of potential issues. This is a great feature if you live in an area with a very specific threat – such as hurricanes or tornados. The only downside to Amica is they don’t provide as many discount opportunities as other insurance firms.

Esurance

Esurance is an insurance company designed for the modern consumer – they allow for quick online quotes and range of other digital benefits. You can access quick quotes and claims directly through their website. They also offer some great discount opportunities for their clients. Esurance is a good choice if you want a digital insurance company built for the 21st Century.

Farmers

Farmers is another of the largest insurance companies in the country. The firm provides a vast range of different insurance offerings for all types of drivers and vehicles – they’re a one-stop-shop for many consumers. They have an on-hand 24/7 claims processing center, as well as an easy-to-use claims management system. With Farmers, you benefit from the strength and resources of a large company.

GEICO

GEICO is one of America’s most famous insurance companies – the company is known for its gecko character in its various television ads. The company specializes in providing auto insurance to consumers. As the second biggest auto insurance company in the US, GEICO has the resources to provide auto insurance to all types of drivers and vehicles. GEICO has decent customer service ratings and has recently introduced plenty of great tech solutions that improve customers’ digital functionality.

The General

The General is an auto insurance provider that is known for providing policies to high-risk drivers in the United States. While the General does provide high-risk insurance, their prices also tend to be less competitive than many other providers in the industry. Also, they have a reputation for disputing claims and causing headaches for customers. Last, there are also some hidden fees associated with their services – this may make the real cost of their insurance much higher than originally advertised.

Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual, another giant in the US auto insurance industry, has a reputation for providing great coverage at affordable rates. They also have an online claims processing portal that makes the entire claims process much easier. Liberty Mutual also offers various discounts to their customers. The only downside to their insurance policies is that they seem to provide less claim satisfaction than some of the other large insurance providers in the niche.

MetLife

MetLife is another large insurance company in the United States, but it doesn’t provide as many benefits as some of the other insurers mentioned on this list. One major benefit is that MetLife does have a program that rewards responsible driving. If you’ve managed to keep a clean driving record for a prolonged period of time, you’ll most likely be able to get a solid premium from MetLife. All this being said, their claims process has a reputation for taking much longer than it should. It may be worth considering a different insurer if you want quick claims.

Nationwide

Nationwide is one of America’s largest auto insurance providers. The company is great if you want to work with an insurance firm that offers a range of different policies and coverage options – though they don’t offer anything for rideshare drivers. Nationwide is also well-known for their 24/7 claims service and great customer support – they have a much better claim record than many of the other competitors on the market.

Progressive

Progressive is a great insurance company if you’re looking for value for money. As one of the largest insurance firms in the nation, Progressive has the strength to provide a wide range of custom policies tailored to suit the needs of drivers – they even offer policies for people who don’t use their vehicles as often as traditional drivers. Best of all, if you’re under 18, Progressive has some of the best discounts in the nation.

State Farm

State Farm benefits from one of the largest insurance agent networks in the country. This is a great benefit if you’re looking to meet face-to-face with an agent before you purchase your next policy. Also, State Farm is considered one of the strongest performers in the industry, according to a variety of different industry monitors. The company also has a great track record for successful claims. As the largest auto insurance provider in the nation, State Farm is able to provide insurance services to all 50 states of the country – a feature that not many other insurance companies can claim.

The Hartford

The Hartford isn’t as well-known as some of the other insurance providers on this page, but they offer some of the best benefits in the industry. The Hartford uses plenty of tools to help you improve your overall insurance experience. For example, you can receive online quotes and purchase a policy without ever leaving the comfort of your home. They also have a great customer support team and solid claims process. If you’re looking for a new insurance company that provides all the digital benefits that you need, the Hartford is a relatively affordable choice.

Travelers

Travelers is an auto insurance company well-known for its range of features and benefits. They provide their clients with rental vehicles and other benefits while repairs are being done on damages. In addition, they have some great coverage benefits that include accident forgiveness programs and other features. The only downside to Travelers’ current offering is that they don’t have as good of a reputation with claims as some of their competitors.

21st Century

If you’re looking for an auto insurance company that provides plenty of customer policies, you might find 21st Century an interesting option. The company provides plenty of custom options that can help you ensure you only pay for what you want. Unfortunately, they don’t have an accident forgiveness program so an accident may substantially increase your insurance premiums in certain instances. 21st Century does provide new car replacement if your vehicle is less than one year old – this is a great feature if you get in an accident with a relatively new vehicle.

How to Save on Car Insurance

If you’re looking to save money, one of the best ways to improve your income is to save on auto insurance. Auto insurance can be very expensive if you don’t know how to reduce your costs. Fortunately, there are a few different things you can do to improve your chances of reducing your car insurance rates. Below, we’ll explore a few of these different strategies in further detail. Check them out!

Cheap Auto Insurance Companies

Improve Your Credit

Believe it or not, but your credit score often plays a large role in your auto insurance rates. Car insurance providers will often look at your credit score to determine how responsible you are. While this might not seem fair, it’s essential that you understand your credit score plays a vital role. Improving your score before applying for a policy can ensure that you receive a reduction in your current insurance rates. Don’t underestimate how important this can be!

Paying down your current credit card debt and removing items from your credit report can help you improve your credit quickly. If you think you’ll apply for a new auto insurance policy in the near future, it’s definitely worth trying to improve your credit score. This can also help you take advantage of other financial opportunities in the near future!

Request Quotes Regularly – Assess the Market

Many people overpay for their auto insurance because they’re lazy. If you want the best price for your next auto insurance policy, it’s essential that you check new quotes from different insurance companies. Don’t keep paying extra for car insurance because it’s convenient – take back control of your policy by understanding the market. If you constantly look for better rates, you’re much more likely to find an affordable insurance policy. The insurance market can change quickly. Using comparison tools to receive quotes can ensure you’re not overpaying for your current policy.

Talk to Your Insurer

If you think you’re overpaying, but you like your current insurance provider, speak to them about receiving discounts on your current policy. Some insurance companies are much more flexible than you realize. If you do decide to explore this option, make sure that you come prepared with a solid case of why you should receive a discount. For example, you may want to cite that you have a perfect driving record and a no-claims history.

Decide if Comprehensive is Worth the Money

It’s easy to get wrapped up in a comprehensive insurance policy. Many people make the mistake of paying over-the-top costs for comprehensive insurance because it provides the most security. While comprehensive insurance ensures that the cost of your vehicle is protected in the case of an accident, if your vehicle is old or has little value, this might not be the best option. Assess if purchasing comprehensive insurance is likely to cost you more money than replacing the value of your current vehicle. Those with cars under the cost of $3,000 may find that comprehensive insurance is relatively worthless.

Check the Reputation of Your Auto Insurance Company Before You Make Agreements

Many people make the mistake of choosing the cheapest auto insurance company on the market. While it’s easy to want to use the cheap car insurance company you find, it’s essential that you do enough background research on the company before you make any decisions.

For example, The General provides auto insurance to high-risk drivers – they also don’t have completely unaffordable plans. Unfortunately, the company has a bad reputation with consumers. They often deny claims and have a weak customer service department. If you want to work with a company that respects its customers, you need to ensure you check consumer watchdog groups for complaints or testimonials. The Better Business Bureau and Consumer Affairs are two great places to check before you agree to a policy. These sites allow consumers to review companies they work with – it’s a great way to get a good idea about the reliability of an auto insurance company.

Verdict: Assess, Compare, and Contrast

At the end of the day, the best way to find cheap auto insurance is to understand what you’re looking for. Find an auto insurance company that provides discounts or incentives that you’ll be able to take advantage of. Many auto insurance companies now allow individuals to receive quotes online – it’s a great way to check several auto insurance companies before making any commitments. Unlike credit cards, you don’t have to agree to a quote once you apply for one – you can always take a better offer.

Staying on top of your auto insurance is the best way to ensure you have a cheap auto insurance policy. Don’t get complacent – check for new quotes regularly and stay in contact with your insurance company. If you’ve been working with the same insurance company for years, ask for concessions – if they don’t agree, there are plenty of other cheap car insurance options on the market.

FAQ

Auto Insurance Recommendations

Cheap is good, but make sure it covers everything you’re looking for. This section would help you achieve just that.

test
Your content goes here. Edit or remove this text inline or in the module Content settings. You can also style every aspect of this content in the module Design settings and even apply custom CSS to this text in the module Advanced settings.
What is a good car insurance company?

A good insurance company charges reasonable rates for your coverage, quickly responds when you are entitled to compensation, and provides fair compensation for damages.

How do I choose a car insurance company?

The most important thing to look for is its reputation and financial stability. For example, veer away from companies that have been involved in multiple bad faith lawsuits.

What company has the best car insurance for teenage drivers?

Although their area of service is not as expansive as State Farm or Geico, Erie Insurance is the best pick as they offer huge discounts to students under 21 and even give you opportunities to even lower your rate.

What car insurance companies cover salvage titles?

Omni, Progressive, and Safeco are only some of the companies offering insurance on salvage titles.

What is the best insurance company for auto and home?

Nationwide is listed as the cheapest with annual costs at $2,445 and State Farm as the most generous with discounts at 10%.

Who is the number one auto insurance company?

Considering market share alone, State Farm is definitely the number one with $41.8 billion in premiums collected in 2017.

What car insurance companies offer gap insurance?

Allstate, Nationwide, Esurance, and USAA all offer gap insurance. Other companies offer a slightly different policy which cannot be classified under the same name.

Which car insurance companies do not check credit?

Try telematics and usage-based insurance companies such as Metromile. However, if you’re in Hawaii, California, and Massachusetts, your credit score can’t be used for or against you at all.

What insurance companies offer new car replacement?

Almost all companies that offer car insurance, but they have certain requirements that you have to meet for you to eligible.

Which auto insurance company has the best claims service?

According to Insure, USAA reigns supreme. But because you need military affiliation to have an account with them, consider Allstate as the close second.

What car insurance companies offer military discounts?

Aside from USAA, GEICO, Arabella Insurance (only available in Massachusetts), and Direct General are all good options.

What auto insurance companies insure Uber drivers?

All companies offering your ‘regular’ car insurance also have specific policies to cater Uber drivers.

What auto insurance companies offer 12-month policies?

Erie Insurance, Liberty Mutual, Infinity, MetLife, and National General Insurance all offer 12-month policies if you meet certain eligibility requirements.

What insurance companies offer non-owner car insurance?

There are only five that offer this type of insurance – GEICO, State Farm, The General, Nationwide, and Titan.

Which companies offer temporary car insurance?

Unfortunately, this type of service is not commonly offered in the United States. You always have the option to go to them and try to give you a short-term insurance.

Accidents, Claims, and Other Related Issued

When the worst happens, how would you handle it? Always be on top of every unfortunate situation with this section as your guide.

test
Your content goes here. Edit or remove this text inline or in the module Content settings. You can also style every aspect of this content in the module Design settings and even apply custom CSS to this text in the module Advanced settings.
What do I do when car insurance company denies claim?

You must first understand their grounds for denial. If you think these grounds were unreasonable or not supported by facts, you can write a letter to the insurance company, appeal the decision to the State Insurance commissioner, or file a lawsuit.

What can I do if my car insurance company won't pay?

If your claim was approved, they have a duty to compensate you within the time indicated in the contract. You can hire an auto insurance lawyer not only to ensure that they pay up but also to protect your interests.

How do I file a complaint against a car insurance company?

File it directly with your state’s insurance department’s online filing site. From there, you’d see the state process you should follow in filing your complaint.

How do I sue an insurance company after an auto accident?

Build your case by keeping all records of your communication with them as well as all potential evidence related to the claim. Then, hire a lawyer to represent you.

How do I settle a car accident without an insurance company?

The key here is to keep documentation of what you have agreed upon and to fulfill have been settled. Also, make sure that the other party does not involve his insurance company.

When do I notify the insurance company of a car accident?

Many insurers require you to notify them within 72 hours of the accident. However, as reporting them is not a legal requirement, you might want to try to settle the issue for minor accidents like a broken side mirror.

How do I negotiate with insurance company after car accident?

You don’t have to. After a car accident, you have to file a claim first. The negotiation (in the form of a compensation offer) would come from them.

How do I settle a claim with auto insurance company?

Determine the minimum amount that you would accept based on the expenses related to the accident. Most importantly, when communicating with them, stick to facts and not speculations as that can potentially lower your settlement.

How do I report a car accident to insurance company?

You report it through a claim. In your claim, take pictures, record, and gather evidence to strengthen your case.

How much do insurance companies pay for car accidents?

An insurance adjuster is in charge of putting a monetary value on all the losses and damages that have been incurred in a car accident. Of course, the value would vary depending on the gravity of the case.

How do auto insurance companies determine pain and suffering?

There are two ways: multiplying your medical bills by a certain number from 1 to 6 or assigning a fixed amount representing each day is multiplied by the number of days until full recovery.

How do insurance companies determine fault in an auto accident?

Insurance companies will base this on the facts of the case. For example, the one who was speeding is more likely to be at fault than the other who’s below speed limit.

How long does it take insurance company to investigate auto theft?

Most insurance companies assign 30 days for the investigation and potential recovery of the vehicle.

How long after a car is stolen will the insurance company pay?

It can take anywhere from two weeks to a few months. If the insurance company’s special investigations unit is involved, there would be delay with the investigations and payment.

What do I do if auto insurance company is stalling?

There’s nothing like a letter addressed to the company to get them moving. An insurance company will always want to avoid lawsuit, and paper trail greatly strengthens your case against them.

What happens if my car insurance company goes bust?

There’s no need to worry because every insurance company has a special fund meant to pay all pending claims should they go bankrupt.

How do I find out someone’s car insurance company?

If you got their plate, you can go to the DMV and make a request for that information. Make sure that you have a valid reason supported by documents and facts to file that request before doing so.

Totaled Car Concerns

Instead of paying for repairs for your vehicle, you’re compensated instead. But what are its implications? Read on to find out.

test
Your content goes here. Edit or remove this text inline or in the module Content settings. You can also style every aspect of this content in the module Design settings and even apply custom CSS to this text in the module Advanced settings.
What happens when an insurance company totals your car?

They would purchase your car for whatever its value was before the accident instead of paying for repairs.

When does an insurance company total a car?

They total a car if they assessed that the repair expenses are higher than the value of the car. Some states, however, have a minimum value of repair damages required before the insurer can total the car.

How do insurance companies determine value of a totaled car?

They have a software to help them determine the value and consider any recent repairs you have made on the car. To get a ballpark figure, you can refer to the Kelly Blue Book.

How do I fight insurance company totaled car?

You can debunk the basis of their totaling your car. Also, you can ask them as many questions as you can or ask for their basis of totaling your car, and see how you can use those in your favor.

How do I buy a totaled car from insurance company?

Visit the auction site or salvage dealer where the insurance company send your vehicle. From there, you can purchase it.

How do I deal with insurance companies on car total claims?

If the value of the car or the potential claim is significant, it is highly suggested that you employ a lawyer. While they may take a share of your settlement, they would also best negotiate your case and ensure that you get what you deserve.

Understanding Insurance Companies

Know more about the entity you entrust to give you financial protection in accidents.

test
Your content goes here. Edit or remove this text inline or in the module Content settings. You can also style every aspect of this content in the module Design settings and even apply custom CSS to this text in the module Advanced settings.
Who regulates auto insurance companies?

Depending on your state, it may be called Department of Insurance, Insurance Bureau, Division of Insurance, or something to that effect.

How often do car insurance companies check your driving record?

Assuming that you don’t get into accidents, they’ll check your record every three or four years.

What do car insurance companies look at in your records?

They look for signs (usually in the form of tickets and reports) that will statistically increase the possibility of your filing a claim.

How far back do auto insurance companies check?

As they check every three or four years, they don’t look at what they have already reviewed before unless you’ve been in a serious accident.

Why do car insurance companies run credit checks?

They run credit checks because they have data supporting a correlation of credit rating and filing a claim.

Why would a car insurance company drop you?

The most common reason is your nonpayment. Also, if you get into too many accidents, they may deem you too risky and drop you as well.

How do auto insurance companies determine rates?

They look into many factors that they believe are relevant to your likelihood of filing a claim such as driving record, age, gender, credit rating, type of vehicle, and many more.

How do I fight back the insurance company when raising your auto insurance?

If you honestly don’t know why your rates increased, you can first ask your insurance agent. It is not worth fighting the company if you feel their reasons aren’t justified, so just move on to another insurer.

Other Questions on Cheap Auto Insurance

With every concern already covered, this section would address any remaining questions you may still have including switching insurance companies and finding out how insurance companies think.

test
Your content goes here. Edit or remove this text inline or in the module Content settings. You can also style every aspect of this content in the module Design settings and even apply custom CSS to this text in the module Advanced settings.
How do I switch car insurance companies?

To avoid penalties, check first with your insurance carrier what happens if you terminate the policy. If there isn’t any, apply and get approved first before cancelling your old insurance.

What won't car insurance companies tell you?

A lot, actually. But the biggest thing is that they total your car to save money. In fact, 80% of cars involved in collision are declared as totaled.